Whispers of the Library Eau de Toilette by Maison Martin Margiela Review
This isn’t the literal smell of a book. Not even close. But it is a lovely academic sort of aromatic vanilla.
Whispers in the Library by Maison Martin Margiela is a very simple vanilla leaning towards woody and fresh spicy more than towards something gourmand or sweet.
This is a doughier, more playdough-like take on the simple, fluffy white vanilla of something aromatic like Diptyque’s Eau Duelle. It’s not obnoxiously sweet. More like light marshmallow candy: fluffy and doughy, but not over-saturated in sugar crystals.
At the edge, there’s a very faint hint of aromatic, herbaceous green spice. It’s less of a note of its own and more of something that shapes the vanilla. Perhaps there’s the faintest faraway edge of black pepper, hardly detectable at the nadir of the breath. But this feels more like a fresh green spiciness than anything really peppery.
Woody notes? I certainly don’t get any. Supposedly there’s cedar in this — how often do you see a designer base without an obligatory cedar note these days? — but I don’t smell it. (Honestly, I suspect that frequent cedar base note might just be a nice way to say Iso E Super, which might be there more for general depth and musky dimension than a specifically cedar-like effect.)
On me, the drydown of this is a dead ringer for the drydown of Eau Duelle. It’s missing all the greens and spices cushioning the opening of Eau Duelle, but the woodsy-vanilla heart is the same here, with hints of what smells like tobacco and a whisper of what occasionally feels like a white floral note to me that I’m surprised more people haven’t mentioned.
I think Eau Duelle may win here for performance and longevity reasons, as well as my love for the aromatic green notes, but that lead is slight. Whispers in the Library is a little too doughy and sweet for me, although it’s far from the sweetest or doughiest vanilla out there. I have samples of each and I definitely wouldn’t need or want more of both of them, since they’re so similar.
Is Whispers in the Library anything like books? It’s vanillin. Very old breaking down paper and glue do release vanillin, among many other aromachemicals. But there’s much more to the smell of a musty, dusty old book, and none of that is here. No paper, no ink, no dust or decay. Just the soft, cozy vanilla.
Don’t let the “whispers” fool you. Sure, this might be a more polite, less brazen perfume than something like Jazz Club. But it still performs at a respectable level. It’s a bit more of an intimate vanilla scent than a bombastic loud statement piece, sure, but it’s not a faint skin scent in terms of volume.
No, Whispers in the Library projects and performs at a decent level. It’ll last all day, clinging close to the skin but not invisible.
This is a nice, simple vanilla, aromatic and not too sweet. It feels to me like a slightly doughier version of Eau Duelle but without the green aromatics, light and springy and very easily wearable. It’s deliciously soft and fluffy without being at all cloying, heavy, or gourmand.
Whispers in the Library isn’t challenging like Atelier Cologne’s Vanille Insensée or Imaginary Authors’ Memoirs of a Trespasser or even as complex as the relatively simpler Eau Duelle. It’s a simple, faintly spiced, slightly aromatic vanilla. Subdued and simplistic. Nothing to write home about, but it makes you smile a little all the same. Vanillin is the world’s most beloved aroma molecule, after all.
There’s not much else to say here. It’s a nice faint vanilla that leans more towards green, fresh spicy, and woody than towards any sort of cupcake. It doesn’t smell at all like a library or particularly like a book, but it’s pleasant and light and easy to wear.
It blends well with the light academia variant of the so-called dark academia aesthetic. This is white marble and tweed and studying your history books while wearing light-colored linens and drinking cream-colored lattes.
If you want to smell like something like a book but the more literal glossy photographs of Wallpaper* STEIDL’s Paper Passion and the cheap pen ink of Lalique’s Encre Noire, a bookish woody vanilla is a solid choice. Diptyque’s Eau Duelle would be my personal first choice, but Whispers in the Library is a solid one. It’s a simple vanilla without a ton of extra sugar poured on top or many bells and whistles.
The ad copy for Whispers in the Library describes it as “the slowing down of time between books and the whispers of turning pages.” Perhaps that’s accurate enough. If this is at all like the experience of a book, it’s like the quiet and stillness of time when you really settle in to read a physical book.
Simple and pleasant.
Whispers in the Library Eau de Toilette by Maison Martin Margiela
You can find samples and decants of Whispers in the Library EdT at Scent Split.
This is an affiliate link. If you click on it and buy something, the seller pays me a commission, at no extra cost to you. You can learn more about them here.